"If you want a rainbow, you have to put up with a lot of rain... "
It's such an un-pop word, umbrella
The idea of taking something so ordinary and mundane and transforming into an exotic sounding metaphor is quite a feat; but its also one that hasnt gone unnoticed by other bands. Weve already seen covers from the likes of Vanilla Sky, Biffy Clyro and of course the Klaxons. So what is it that makes this version different from the rest?
When most serious bands cover pop songs they end up ruining the song because they insist on taking their most irritating traits (being male and boring) and superimposing it onto what was originally a quite fun piece.*
The Manics dont fall into this trap; the production is explicitly POP, and James doesnt hold back at all, just listen to the chorus and the way he sings the phrase ella, eey eyy !
If youre still offended at the idea of the Manics covering a pop song then remember the following: The Manics are supposed to be a controversial band. Think about it, why wouldnt the Manics want to record a cover which is guaranteed to polarize their fanbase and make a predominantly male centric, guitar biased, indie snob alternative fan base re examine their opinions?
Plus, you know it helps drag new fans in which is always a good thing.
Sheraz Qureshi / Jess Hall, Experiments In Living
*For proof download Travis cover of Hit Me Baby One More Time.